So you KNOW you can hear the difference between lossy and lossless.

Advertise at AfterDawn.com

Link to us!

Private messages

Compose a private message

List of all updated threads

Threads without replies

Search messages

Tuesday 15.10.2024 / 19:14

Search AfterDawn Forums:

afterdawn.com > forums > digital audio > audio > so you know you can hear the difference between lossy and lossless.

Browse by topic

Forums

Start a new thread

So you KNOW you can hear the difference between lossy and lossless.

Jump to:

Posted

Message

Mez

AfterDawn Addict

9. August 2013 @ 14:23

Link to this message

So you KNOW you can hear the difference between lossy and lossless.

The first thing I say to this is the difference between high quality lossy and lossless is negligible in that 1% of music recordings that there may actually be different. Since you claim you can hear the difference when they are identical might indicate you are delusional. Let me explain?

a quote from http://journal.plasticmind.com/ears/mos...oure-a-youngun/

Quote:
Now for those of you who don't follow pop culture and web trends, et. al, a "mosquito tone" is simply a 17KHz sine wave that geeky youngsters have been known to use on their cell phone to alert them when they've got a text message so the teachers can't hear it. See, studies say that most of us old folks (I'm over 30 now) can't hear much above the 13-14KHz range.

The page has hearing tests and a hearing chart

http://journal.plasticmind.com/assets/12ring-graphic.gif

Just incase the site gets deleted here is some of what is in the chart

Note - the low end is for persons that do not listen to loud music or noises, ever. It has NOTHING to do with your IQ.
18 ? 24 yrs can hear up to 16 kHz
30 ? 39 yrs can hear up to 15 kHz
40 ? 49 yrs can hear up to 13 kHz
50 ? 59 yrs can hear up to 12 kHz
To hear 20 kHz you need to be maybe 5 yrs old
Highest note on a piano 4KHz
Highest note produced by a human voice 2kHz

Lame VBR at its second highest setting captures 19383 Hz - 19916 Hz. I could not find what the highest setting but it is likely to be 20,000 or the same as lossless or so close to it doesn?t matter. Even at 19916 the difference is 1%. Hearing is one of our least accurate senses. Claiming that you can tell the difference between lossless and lossy is pretty much an ignorant boast. It assumes that what you are listening to actually has some note that is higher than 199920 Hz which is rare. 1) Probably in a random sampling of popular music probably less than 3 out of the hundred recordings ACTUALLY HAS a 20,000 Hz note. Since most recording do not have 20,000 Hz tones and you think you can hear the difference when there is none you are deluding yourself. 2) Even if you have a recording that has a 20kHz tone loud enough for you to hear, it is still like claiming if you are looking at a 100 ft tree you can reliably see at a glance if the tree was only 99 ft high. It has to be at a glance since the resonance tone may not last for even a second. Remember sight is out most accurate sense while hearing is our least accurate sense. #0 Lastly, the high tones are only resonances. A high C is not even 2 kHz. Primary notes of any instrument are all below 5 kHz. Fletcher?Munson effect (to hear tones as the frequency increases the loudness must increase log rhythmically to be able to hear it) requires a tone that is 99.99% of your hearing limit to be over 100 times as loud as the primary note to be able to hear it which they can?t be since they are only resonances.

[ + quote]

This message has been edited since posting. Last time this message was edited on 9. August 2013 @ 14:46

aldan

Senior Member

10. August 2013 @ 00:15

Link to this message

hey mez,any sites you could recommend that give a hearing test like this? im 55 and curious as to how the rock concerts and impact wrenches (pulled wrenches for 35 years) have affected my hearing.

[ + quote]

xboxdvl2

Senior Member

10. August 2013 @ 06:52

Link to this message

alden in my opinion an online hearing test wouldn't work as it would depend on your speaker settings and test results would be unreliable.

I'm curious as to how good my hearing is.my eye sight gets worse every year and sounds seem to be getting closer and louder.most the time i have music on just to drown out any background noise i can hear.

(some examples) My washing machine during spin sounds like a helicopters landing on my roof,my nieghbours lawnmower sounds like 3 chainsaws going at once,i hear what sounds like someone stomp on the ground every wednesday morning but its just my messenger newspaper getting thrown onto soft grass.

[ + quote]

custom built gaming pc from early 2010,ps2 with 15 games all original,ps3 500gbs with 5 games all original,yamaha amp and 5.1channel surround sound speakers,46inch sony lcd smart tv.

aldan

Senior Member

10. August 2013 @ 11:40

Link to this message

yeah,hearing,eyesight,back,knees,mind.LOL.

[ + quote]

Mez

AfterDawn Addict

11. August 2013 @ 23:31

Link to this message

The first link included a hearing test (at the bottom). Most ear buds go at least to 20,000 Hz mine go 22 kHz but I couldn't hear 17 kHz on the test. High frequencies are cheap to reproduce but expensive to store.

Note: Most hearing tests make the very high tones very loud. If you can hear a tone at 120 DB you can hear it. That does not mean you can hear a resonance tone at 20 db on a recording.

The reason why I stipulated solos is other instruments will mask the resonance tones. Example you do not expect to hear people whispering during an explosion. The explosion is a loud and low frequency. Your hearing favors low frequencies. I remember ripping a classical guitar using VBR -0 setting; the tracks were over 320 BR even though the estimated was maybe 200. VBR is a quality setting not a BR setting.

[ + quote]

Start a new thread

afterdawn.com > forums > digital audio > audio > so you know you can hear the difference between lossy and lossless.


		User name	Password

		Not registered yet? Register here. Lost your password? Click here.