|
Internet piracy trial against The Pirate Bay begins
|
|
The following comments relate to this news article:
article published on 16 February, 2009
The Internet piracy trial brought forward by Sweden against the admins of the infamous torrent tracker The Pirate Bay is set to begin today and with it comes the fate of the world's largest public tracker.
Fredrik Neij, Gottfrid Svartholm, Peter Sunde and Carl Lundstroem are each accused of "promoting violations by other people of laws protecting royalties," and are being sued for $17.6 ... [ read the full article ]
Please read the original article before posting your comments.
|
|
joebloe12
Junior Member
|
16. February 2009 @ 02:45 |
Link to this message
|
|
This ought to be interesting.....
|
|
Advertisement
|
|
|
|
|
Jhult
Junior Member
|
16. February 2009 @ 02:48 |
Link to this message
|
Now this will definitely be interesting. Most notably due to the fact that they are suing them over the fact that their official statement says that they are being sued due to the act of "Providing the possibility for others to make pirate copies of big commercial productions, movies, music and popular computer games.". I mean if I just read that right, does that not mean that the producers of such things to begin with were also providing the material to be stolen in the first place? I mean the claim can be broadly applied to anyone who has a DVD burner or CD-ROM burner who has proper copying programs does it not?
|
Member
|
16. February 2009 @ 03:56 |
Link to this message
|
Even if they do go down, they've still got a hundred more to go, and lets not forget the file hosting sites aswell. i think the MPAA -(and so on) are fighting losing battle here!
And i dont know why they keep telling us that downloading music, games, films etc is stealing... its not stealing, its called "sharing" if it was called stealing, why would the owner upload it to the internet for evryone else to download in the first place?! I think they need t get their prospective right about this!!! *Deep Breaths*
I personaly hope The Pirate Bay somehow does win the trial, as it'll be a milestone to show that the MPAA -(and so on) are losing.
|
|
plazma247
Member
|
16. February 2009 @ 05:06 |
Link to this message
|
|
|
|
domie
Member
|
16. February 2009 @ 06:38 |
Link to this message
|
no particular strong viewpoint one way or the other but this caught my eye : -
Quote:
Prosecutors have claimed that the site makes $4 million USD a year, however Sunde says the site is a money losing operation.
that explains how the owners were only able to afford one luxury penthouse apartment each in Stockholm and why they only have 5 other houses between them scattered around Europe. Times must be hard when you only make 4 million a year.
either way, no point arguing about it - the truth will come out in the trial.
|
|
jeff_2
Junior Member
|
16. February 2009 @ 06:40 |
Link to this message
|
|
What i would pay to be that court room
|
|
plazma247
Member
|
16. February 2009 @ 06:40 |
Link to this message
|
|
you would have thought that they could o forked out on a better looking bus, omg it looks like the one used in on the buses in the 1970's lol
|
Junior Member
|
16. February 2009 @ 11:53 |
Link to this message
|
No matter the outcome. If TPB goes down, there will be more sites in it's place to re-appear. Or as in what's already happened. They'll go down and they'll be back better than before. The MPAA and RIAA do this just to annoy their selves I swear.
|
Junior Member
|
16. February 2009 @ 11:55 |
Link to this message
|
|
What meant to put in my last post is, if you follow the file sharing trend. All this stuff does it make the sharing technology evolve. There most likely in the future will be a better way to share that they won't know enough about until it's to big just its always been.
|
Newbie
|
16. February 2009 @ 12:45 |
Link to this message
|
i don't know about you guys, but the fate of my entertainment lies in this trial.
|
|
windsong
Member
1 product review
|
16. February 2009 @ 14:18 |
Link to this message
|
Originally posted by Kaije:
i don't know about you guys, but the fate of my entertainment lies in this trial.
What is wrong with ISOhunt? Emule? Usenet? Other misc P2p? Ive never understood why pirate bay is as popular as it is. Ive gotten maybe a gigs worth over the years from them, and even then only if its uber rare stuff I couldn't get anywhere else. What is it about pirate bay that makes it the best? Trackers, users, or content?
Though I admit emule probably isn't many peoples favorite on account of files taking so long to download, and USenet, well..it does help if you shell out 15 a month for a premium usenet provier like Giga. Or perhaps Pirate Bay is for the most part appealing to the under-18 crowd who don't want to wade through the endless list of newsgroup readers to find one suited to them?
Mystery.
|
Junior Member
|
16. February 2009 @ 14:22 |
Link to this message
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Kaije:
i don't know about you guys, but the fate of my entertainment lies in this trial.
What is wrong with ISOhunt? Emule? Usenet? Other misc P2p? Ive never understood why pirate bay is as popular as it is. Ive gotten maybe a gigs worth over the years from them, and even then only if its uber rare stuff I couldn't get anywhere else. What is it about pirate bay that makes it the best? Trackers, users, or content?
Though I admit emule probably isn't many peoples favorite on account of files taking so long to download, and USenet, well..it does help if you shell out 15 a month for a premium usenet provier like Giga. Or perhaps Pirate Bay is for the most part appealing to the under-18 crowd who don't want to wade through the endless list of newsgroup readers to find one suited to them?
Mystery.
I agree. I barely use TPB at all. Maybe once or twice a year I used them on avg. But Newsgroups are my place of choice and private trackers.
|
|
thor999
Member
|
16. February 2009 @ 23:39 |
Link to this message
|
|
Do you take cash? LOL Those guys can afford twice that, trust me. And you know what? Fu%@ 'em 'cuz they don't monitor any of the trash thats frequently overpopulating our networks needlessly, and rarely is it the intended file anyways. They aren't pioneers, they're pimps.
|
Newbie
|
17. February 2009 @ 02:02 |
Link to this message
|
Originally posted by windsong:
Originally posted by Kaije:
i don't know about you guys, but the fate of my entertainment lies in this trial.
What is wrong with ISOhunt? Emule? Usenet? Other misc P2p? Ive never understood why pirate bay is as popular as it is. Ive gotten maybe a gigs worth over the years from them, and even then only if its uber rare stuff I couldn't get anywhere else. What is it about pirate bay that makes it the best? Trackers, users, or content?
Though I admit emule probably isn't many peoples favorite on account of files taking so long to download, and USenet, well..it does help if you shell out 15 a month for a premium usenet provier like Giga. Or perhaps Pirate Bay is for the most part appealing to the under-18 crowd who don't want to wade through the endless list of newsgroup readers to find one suited to them?
Mystery.
nothing's wrong with them i guess. new to the whole torrent thing so if mininova doesn't have it, i go to pirate bay. but don't you think that if the trial is a success for the prosecution, that it will eventually lead to more trials to come? granted, it will be difficult, but if one becomes a success, it could make it easier to follow through with more.
|
|
Mez
AfterDawn Addict
|
17. February 2009 @ 08:52 |
Link to this message
|
spydah, much of what is on ISOhunt and mininova is provided by PB.
dcity, are they fighting a losing battle? I don't think so! Where have you been? They have regrouped and are working on more permanent ways to shut down P2P. They have already changed laws in maybe a dozen countries making P2P illegal. These changes are so common they are not news ay more. I am guessing by the end of this year P2P will be illegal in most countries and P2P as we know it will be DEAD! There has been a massive infusion of money into the anti-P2P. I would guess there has been more than 100 times as much money spent on anti-P2P in the last 6 months than in the last 10 years. The amonut of money being spent is probably still accelerating. The attacks will be comming from new vectors as well as old. All attacks will be much better funded than in the old days.
I am sure P2P as we know it, is losing huge. I suspect the damage will be more apparent in a few months than it is now.
That is my 2 cents.
|
Senior Member
|
17. February 2009 @ 09:32 |
Link to this message
|
|
Well, I will be sorry to see TPB go. I don't mean to be pessimistic but unless these sites are willing to move OS... I mean AfterDawn chose to stay put and had to conform.
My guess is we will see the rise of RapidShare and similar sites, now that search engines for such have evolved.
|
|
GernBlan
Junior Member
|
17. February 2009 @ 13:00 |
Link to this message
|
Originally posted by Jhult:
Now this will definitely be interesting. Most notably due to the fact that they are suing them over the fact that their official statement says that they are being sued due to the act of "Providing the possibility for others to make pirate copies of big commercial productions, movies, music and popular computer games.". I mean if I just read that right, does that not mean that the producers of such things to begin with were also providing the material to be stolen in the first place? I mean the claim can be broadly applied to anyone who has a DVD burner or CD-ROM burner who has proper copying programs does it not?
What about all the people who manufacturer DVD and CD burners? iPod owners? Apple? Dell? DVD/CD media manufacturers? Where does it end? Pirate Bay will win his suit because what's next? Shouldn't they be going after Al Gore? Afterall, he "invented the internet" and no one could do any of this stuff without the internet.
This is nothing but legal thugging, where someone with a lot of money and time pays a lawyers a lot of money to financially ruin someone -- not necessarily to win the case...just to give lawyers a lot of money, because they know that they can afford it and the accused typically can't.
|
|
mumra1st
Newbie
|
17. February 2009 @ 15:10 |
Link to this message
|
This is all a perfect example of why the world is in a recession - greed. Overpaid movie stars, producers, agents, directors etc. all at the expense of the public. If they weren't so greedy they would charge a reasonable amount to view the product and there would be no need to try and subvert the system. What is the difference between taping a show from tv to be viewed later and downloading a movie from a 'friend' to watch later. If I buy a dvd and watch with friends that is illegal according to the industry. If I lend it to my brother that is illegal. Fortunately the judges can see through this one and have made a profit necessary to consider this illegal. So as long as you are not selling the product you should be able to download for say a $.50 to view at home. The movie producers etc would still make a small fortune with each and every movie they produce as well as songs etc. There should be a cap on the percentage of profit that they are allowed to make. I personally know of singers who are constantly ripped off by music producers and receive very little return for their work - most of it siphoned off by the leeches living off their creativity. Go PB - I hope they win. what a message that would be.
|
|
Damon666
Newbie
|
17. February 2009 @ 16:00 |
Link to this message
|
Good Luck to Pirate bay and other share sites. I am a user and I frequently share and download music mainly. If I like it, I usually go and buy the cd / dvd after downloading - if I have some obscure stuff then I like to share. If I download and dont like it, I delete it. I am probably guilty of keeping some files I have not gone out a bought as they are either not available in my country or too damn expensive to buy on my budget. yes I could be seen as a thief, however, I do also feel it promotes as much as it harms. I have downloaded cinema released movies online and actually gone out and bought the dvd when it comes out. Not all of us have access to the cinema but are very inquisitive about seeing the movie - even when the quality is shocking!! Sorry if you disagree.
|
|
apd06
Member
|
17. February 2009 @ 17:24 |
Link to this message
|
PB is a search engine just like google.
If I googled any word ending in torrent google would bring up page after page of file sharing crap.
PB FTW if not then the internet is only good for msn and pron
|
|
SHOU5
Account closed as per user's own request
|
17. February 2009 @ 19:59 |
Link to this message
|
|
This definitely would be interesting. Another plot by companies like the one in Sweden to step on the little guys.... Sue happy people!
|
Junior Member
|
17. February 2009 @ 20:34 |
Link to this message
|
Well I suppose you could interpret the charges to pertain to Google or people with DVD burners, but The Pirate Bay is a direct link to loads of illegal activity. I bet 90% of torrent content is probably illegal to share... Its hard to defend these admins who obviously recognize their website is a direct gate to tons of pirated content. I would like to see them get off, but it'll be hard.
But then again, is it illegal to tell somebody where to buy drugs, or how to make a simple explosive?
I'm sure they saw this coming and set a bunch of money aside for a rainy day just like this.
|
|
kudzul33t
Newbie
|
20. February 2009 @ 16:53 |
Link to this message
|
|
Political or Criminal.....don't think they know yet
~ I was here ~
|
|
Advertisement
|
|
|
|
plazma247
Member
|
21. February 2009 @ 18:54 |
Link to this message
|
|
This message has been edited since posting. Last time this message was edited on 21. February 2009 @ 18:58
|
