Which Transcoding Tools Produce The Best Picture Quality.
|
|
AfterDawn Addict
1 product review
|
6. June 2004 @ 18:35 |
Link to this message
|
64026402
Instant copy is $30 on pinnacles website.
" Please Read!!! Post your questions only in This Thread or they will go unanswered:
Help with development of BD RB: Donations at: http://www.jdobbs.com/.
This message has been edited since posting. Last time this message was edited on 6. June 2004 @ 18:43
|
Advertisement
|
|
|
AfterDawn Addict
1 product review
|
6. June 2004 @ 18:52 |
Link to this message
|
Great Post brobear, You hit it right on the nail for a lot of people. We all need to keep our choices open, and think about the task at hand, and do what our experiences tell us to do. And Then Keep on Burning!!!
" Please Read!!! Post your questions only in This Thread or they will go unanswered:
Help with development of BD RB: Donations at: http://www.jdobbs.com/.
This message has been edited since posting. Last time this message was edited on 6. June 2004 @ 19:22
|
Member
|
6. June 2004 @ 19:06 |
Link to this message
|
Pinnacle Instant Copy Vs. 8 can be purchased for 23.96 plus shipping which is 3.99 UPS to Georgia. This makes total of 27.95.
Best buy I could find......
bigorange, let us know what you come up with after your test.
HP 7975 Pentium 4W/2.0 XP Home
1 GB RAM
Maxtor 80 GB and WD 80 GB (used for movies only)
Pioneer 116 DVD ROM,and BenQ 1640 Combo
|
brobear
Suspended permanently
|
6. June 2004 @ 20:34 |
Link to this message
|
Mistake on the post. Saw the item lower at PCsoft, but shipping and taxes made it higher.
This message has been edited since posting. Last time this message was edited on 6. June 2004 @ 21:40
|
brobear
Suspended permanently
|
6. June 2004 @ 20:57 |
Link to this message
|
One program I don't hear mentioned too often is DVDXCopy Platinum. If a person can get it to work on their system, it is a good recording program. It does have a lot of interference problems. Nero's InCD and Roxio are just 2 of many that can effect the program. It works very good for the mid-size movies, but suffers compression difficulties when one gets up to the big movies. I still find occasion to use it and get excellent results.
The newer RF version has better controls and includes a large user guide in PDF format. It lacks the ripper capacity of the earlier program. That issue is addressed in other threads.
This message has been edited since posting. Last time this message was edited on 6. June 2004 @ 21:03
|
brian100
Suspended due to non-functional email address
|
6. June 2004 @ 22:44 |
Link to this message
|
Sophocles
Quote: This is my thought for smaller files 5.5 gigs and down, use Nero's recode because compression isn't a factor and time is
I disagree with that statement. I am speaking purely through personal experience. If the file length is 5 gigs BUT the movie is, say, over 2 hours, even that apparent mild compression can cause awful results. The major factor I take into consideration when choosing my transcoding/encoding app is movie LENGTH.
Looking for my old AD
|
AfterDawn Addict
|
6. June 2004 @ 22:47 |
Link to this message
|
Brian, must disagree buddy, recode does an excellent job on files that size. Got to go with Sophocles on this one.
|
brian100
Suspended due to non-functional email address
|
6. June 2004 @ 23:02 |
Link to this message
|
bigorange
As i said earlier Buddy, it's purely from personal experience. I stand by my statement.
Looking for my old AD
|
AfterDawn Addict
|
6. June 2004 @ 23:33 |
Link to this message
|
Gentlemen, we have a winner. After 8+ hours I think InstantCopy 8 is well worth 25 bucks(found it for 24.95). I used LOTR-Return of the King since I had already backed it up with recode ,so I had something to compare to and also, I wanted a long movie( this one tops out at 3 1/2 hours) that had action and would test it's meddle. If time isn't a factor(Brian, you weren't kidding about that, & rite on target about InstantCopy's quality!), then this program is another great way to go. Easy to use and compatible with a large number of softwares and it has a ton of options, all the while retaining a working menu. I did 3 burns, 1-on the fly with Anydvd(BTW brobear and Tom, dvd43 also worked flawlessly on one of my other burns)-2+ hours, 2- ripped with Decrypter to HD, then to burn- 3+ hours, 3- ripped with dvd43, then wrote to HD, then to ouput folder, then to burn ( didn't finish this one but estimate about 4+ hours). I then put my recode copy in one dvd player, and each of my Pinnacle copies in another one at a time, put it on a 56" Mitsibushi HDTV and split the screen in half with my PIP. I played, paused, and freeze framed throughout and I gotta say that Pinnacle was superior in all cases. As Sophocles stated in an earlier thread, speed or quality or a happy medium, it's up to you. I will by no means give up recode, still love it, great picture considering I did the same movie in about 1 1/4 hrs. But, damn, I was impressed. To 6402 sq., pull it out of the dustbin and burn baby burn. No problems whatsoever. I went to Mushkin for my guide and used doom 9(http://www.dvdrhelp.com/guides.php?tools=&madeby=&formatconversionselect=&howtoselect=3%3B25&orderby=Topic&listall=1&archive=%25&search=Search+or+List+Guides) for anybody interested. It also comes with a good help file and support. Finally, if I'm up @ the computer,-recode, if I'm goin' to bed,-Instant copy. lol In conclusion, for those of you that haven't tried it use the trial version, I think it gives you 15 days, and let me know what you think. Thanx for starting the thread Sophocles which in turn showed me this wonderful affordable program. Happy Blazing....
GO VOLS !
This message has been edited since posting. Last time this message was edited on 7. July 2004 @ 16:47
|
Member
|
7. June 2004 @ 01:24 |
Link to this message
|
To all.
I now own Pinnacle Instant Copy and it is just what it says. Instant in set up etc. Quality is extra fine but slower than recode.
I burned The Haunted Mansion which I burned before with recode 2. Recode 2 gave same quality as far as I can tell in less time.
Results: analize and recode 38 minutes
burn to disc 24 minutes.
The burn probably would be faster had I used a 6 x media instead of 2.4x. But I was out of 6x. Got some more coming from meritline tomorrow. (Ritak).
The option to turn off screen savers did not work for me. So go ahead and disable your screen savers as you do in anyother burning program before starting Instant Copy.
1. Insstalls a virtual drive (if you want it to during install).
2. Finds all drives etc at start up
3. Good looking graphics
4. Very easy to set up and use.(just set source & pick burner and click start) What could be easier????
5. Has advanced settings which I have not played with yet. I used the default settings.
6. I like the progress clips and information in recode 2 better.
Overall a very good program for 1 click.........
Will stay on my computer and I will give it some playing time on the burning field.
HP 7975 Pentium 4W/2.0 XP Home
1 GB RAM
Maxtor 80 GB and WD 80 GB (used for movies only)
Pioneer 116 DVD ROM,and BenQ 1640 Combo
|
Member
|
7. June 2004 @ 01:46 |
Link to this message
|
To all.
Forgot to insert the Log File concerning my burn with Pinnacle Instant Copy.
6/7/2004 3:54:22 AM
Versions:
Operating System: Windows XP 5.01 (Build 2600: Service Pack 1)
CPU: Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.00GHz (x86 Family 15 Model 1 Stepping 2 SSE2)
InstantCopy : 8.0.0.251
Pinnacle Disc Abstraction Layer : 1.0.0.67
Recording API Events Translation Library: 1.0.1.20
Device Abstraction Layer : 1.0.0.427
Audio resampler : 1.0.0.6
VCD Library : 2.0.6.0
SVCD Library : 2.0.6.0
MPEG2 Video Filter : 1.0.0.24
AC3 Audio Filter : 1.0.0.18
MPEG2 Transcoder Filter : 1.0.0.66
File Dump Filter (Sample) : 8.0.0.10
Pinnacle MPEG2 Sectorbased DVD Reader : 1.0.0.13
Stream Multiplexer : 1.0.0.15
Stream Splitter : 1.0.0.33
Stream Splitter : 1.0.0.33
Settings:
General:
Temporary Directory: C:\DOCUME~1\Owner\LOCALS~1\Temp (53.00 GB of 71.92 GB free)
After simulation: Start writing after confirmation
Programming interface type: Automatic (Recommended)
[X] Disable Screensaver while writing
DVD:
Copy method: Automatic Resize
Preferred Destination: Automatic (Recommended)
Reduction Method: Automatic (Recommended)
CD Aspect Ratio: Automatic (Recommended)
AS:
SP:
CD:
Transfer Mode: Automatic (Recommended)
Strategy: Stop copying on read error
[ ] Use error seek
Error seek range: 0
Write:
Write method: Automatic (Recommended)
Closing method: Automatic (Recommended)
Write speed: Automatic (Recommended)
&Copies: 1
[ ] Overwrite rewritable media without confirmation
[ ] Write to hard disk first
[ ] Simulate writing if possible
Read:
Data read speed: Automatic (Recommended)
Audio read speed: Automatic (Recommended)
Software read retries: 4
[X] Set Hardware retries:
Set Hardware retries: 2
[03:54:22] Retrieving source Disc Information...
[03:54:23] DVD to Disc
[03:54:23] Source Device:
[03:54:23] PIONEER DVD-ROM DVD-116 1.21
[03:54:23] Destination Device:
[03:54:23] _NEC DVD_RW ND-2500A 1.06
[03:54:23] Reading Video Title Sets...
[03:54:24] Could not load analyze data for disc: B18D91C2CCA1BA618001087839418919-0005C000
[03:54:24] Getting audio data size 1 of 13
[03:54:42] Getting audio data size 2 of 13
[03:54:44] Getting audio data size 3 of 13
[03:54:44] Getting audio data size 4 of 13
[03:54:46] Getting audio data size 5 of 13
[03:54:49] Getting audio data size 6 of 13
[03:54:51] Getting audio data size 7 of 13
[03:54:54] Getting audio data size 8 of 13
[03:54:57] Getting audio data size 9 of 13
[03:55:07] Getting audio data size 10 of 13
[03:55:10] Getting audio data size 11 of 13
[03:55:10] Getting audio data size 12 of 13
[03:55:12] Getting audio data size 13 of 13
[03:55:15] Preparing writing...
[03:55:16] Save to hard disk first because of medium type and more then 7 VTS
[03:55:16] Reading Video Data from source
[03:55:16] Analyzing Main Menu
[03:55:16] Analyzing Menu 1 of 13
[03:55:16] Analyzing video title set 1 of 13
[03:55:16] Analyzing Menu 2 of 13
[03:55:16] Analyzing video title set 2 of 13
[03:55:16] Analyzing Menu 3 of 13
[03:55:16] Analyzing video title set 3 of 13
[03:55:16] Analyzing Menu 4 of 13
[03:55:16] Analyzing video title set 4 of 13
[03:55:16] Analyzing Menu 5 of 13
[03:55:16] Analyzing video title set 5 of 13
[03:55:16] Analyzing Menu 6 of 13
[03:55:16] Analyzing video title set 6 of 13
[03:55:16] Analyzing Menu 7 of 13
[03:55:16] Analyzing video title set 7 of 13
[03:55:16] Analyzing Menu 8 of 13
[03:55:16] Analyzing video title set 8 of 13
[03:55:16] Analyzing Menu 9 of 13
[03:55:16] Analyzing video title set 9 of 13
[03:55:16] Analyzing Menu 10 of 13
[03:55:16] Analyzing video title set 10 of 13
[03:55:16] Analyzing Menu 11 of 13
[03:55:16] Analyzing video title set 11 of 13
[03:55:16] Analyzing Menu 12 of 13
[03:55:16] Analyzing video title set 12 of 13
[03:55:16] Analyzing Menu 13 of 13
[03:55:16] Analyzing video title set 13 of 13
[03:55:16] Reading Main Menu
[03:55:16] Initializing...
[03:55:19] Reading...
[03:55:19] MULTIPLEX: Video: 88 Audio: 2 NavPackets: 3
[03:55:20] Reading Menu 1 of 13
[03:55:20] Initializing...
[03:55:23] Reading...
[03:56:27] MULTIPLEX: Video: 53827 Audio: 14058 NavPackets: 1175
[03:56:27] Reading Video Data 1 of 13
[03:56:27] Initializing...
[03:56:31] Reading...
[04:19:01] MULTIPLEX: Video: 1039742 Audio: 212422 NavPackets: 10461
[04:19:01] Reading Menu 2 of 13
[04:19:01] Initializing...
[04:19:03] Reading...
[04:19:03] MULTIPLEX: Video: 181 Audio: 72 NavPackets: 15
[04:19:03] Reading Video Data 2 of 13
[04:19:03] Initializing...
[04:19:05] Reading...
[04:19:06] MULTIPLEX: Video: 641 Audio: 791 NavPackets: 79
[04:19:07] Reading Menu 3 of 13
[04:19:07] Initializing...
[04:19:08] Reading...
[04:19:08] MULTIPLEX: Video: 58 Audio: 36 NavPackets: 7
[04:19:08] Reading Video Data 3 of 13
[04:19:08] Initializing...
[04:19:09] Reading...
[04:19:10] MULTIPLEX: Video: 155 Audio: 0 NavPackets: 3
[04:19:10] Reading Menu 4 of 13
[04:19:10] Initializing...
[04:19:11] Reading...
[04:19:11] MULTIPLEX: Video: 58 Audio: 36 NavPackets: 7
[04:19:12] Reading Video Data 4 of 13
[04:19:12] Initializing...
[04:19:14] Reading...
[04:19:14] MULTIPLEX: Video: 1695 Audio: 253 NavPackets: 19
[04:19:15] Reading Menu 5 of 13
[04:19:15] Initializing...
[04:19:16] Reading...
[04:19:16] MULTIPLEX: Video: 58 Audio: 36 NavPackets: 7
[04:19:17] Reading Video Data 5 of 13
[04:19:17] Initializing...
[04:19:20] Reading...
[04:19:23] MULTIPLEX: Video: 5745 Audio: 1034 NavPackets: 73
[04:19:23] Reading Menu 6 of 13
[04:19:23] Initializing...
[04:19:24] Reading...
[04:19:24] MULTIPLEX: Video: 58 Audio: 36 NavPackets: 7
[04:19:25] Reading Video Data 6 of 13
[04:19:25] Initializing...
[04:19:26] Reading...
[04:19:26] MULTIPLEX: Video: 313 Audio: 324 NavPackets: 57
[04:19:26] Reading Menu 7 of 13
[04:19:26] Initializing...
[04:19:28] Reading...
[04:19:28] MULTIPLEX: Video: 58 Audio: 36 NavPackets: 7
[04:19:29] Reading Video Data 7 of 13
[04:19:29] Initializing...
[04:19:31] Reading...
[04:21:34] MULTIPLEX: Video: 104584 Audio: 14435 NavPackets: 1211
[04:21:34] Reading Menu 8 of 13
[04:21:34] Initializing...
[04:21:36] Reading...
[04:21:36] MULTIPLEX: Video: 58 Audio: 36 NavPackets: 7
[04:21:36] Reading Video Data 8 of 13
[04:21:36] Initializing...
[04:21:39] Reading...
[04:28:56] MULTIPLEX: Video: 372840 Audio: 22883 NavPackets: 4147
[04:28:56] Reading Menu 9 of 13
[04:28:56] Initializing...
[04:28:58] Reading...
[04:28:58] MULTIPLEX: Video: 58 Audio: 36 NavPackets: 7
[04:28:58] Reading Video Data 9 of 13
[04:28:58] Initializing...
[04:29:01] Reading...
[04:31:36] MULTIPLEX: Video: 258624 Audio: 34438 NavPackets: 3025
[04:31:36] Reading Menu 10 of 13
[04:31:36] Initializing...
[04:31:38] Reading...
[04:31:38] MULTIPLEX: Video: 58 Audio: 36 NavPackets: 7
[04:31:38] Reading Video Data 10 of 13
[04:31:38] Initializing...
[04:31:40] Reading...
[04:31:42] MULTIPLEX: Video: 1998 Audio: 2265 NavPackets: 178
[04:31:42] Reading Menu 11 of 13
[04:31:42] Initializing...
[04:31:43] Reading...
[04:31:44] MULTIPLEX: Video: 6 Audio: 36 NavPackets: 7
[04:31:44] Reading Video Data 11 of 13
[04:31:44] Initializing...
[04:31:45] Reading...
[04:31:45] MULTIPLEX: Video: 132 Audio: 3 NavPackets: 3
[04:31:46] Reading Menu 12 of 13
[04:31:46] Initializing...
[04:31:47] Reading...
[04:31:47] MULTIPLEX: Video: 6 Audio: 36 NavPackets: 7
[04:31:48] Reading Video Data 12 of 13
[04:31:48] Initializing...
[04:31:50] Reading...
[04:31:54] MULTIPLEX: Video: 9536 Audio: 1296 NavPackets: 92
[04:31:54] Reading Menu 13 of 13
[04:31:54] Initializing...
[04:31:55] Reading...
[04:31:56] MULTIPLEX: Video: 58 Audio: 36 NavPackets: 7
[04:31:56] Reading Video Data 13 of 13
[04:31:56] Initializing...
[04:31:59] Reading...
[04:32:24] MULTIPLEX: Video: 36924 Audio: 4938 NavPackets: 415
[04:32:25] Finalizing destination...
[04:32:25] Copying disc
[04:32:25] Read source information...
[04:32:25] Prepare destination...
[04:32:38] Copy track 1 of 1
[04:32:38] Reading track data...
[04:56:00] Closing track...
[04:56:39] Finalizing destination...
[04:56:39] Finalizing destination...
HP 7975 Pentium 4W/2.0 XP Home
1 GB RAM
Maxtor 80 GB and WD 80 GB (used for movies only)
Pioneer 116 DVD ROM,and BenQ 1640 Combo
|
AfterDawn Addict
1 product review
|
7. June 2004 @ 04:24 |
Link to this message
|
Brian
I agree that compressiobn even at 5 gigs can cause awful results with the wrong app (DVD shrink0, but any movies I've backed with recode under 5.5 gigs have been to eye, perfect when compared with the original. I can backup a 5.5 gig movie with recode in under 25 minutes. The same can be said for DVD2One right up to the 7 gig range and I can backup a 7 gig plus moive with DVD2One in under 45 minutes. Remember I did a side by side comaparison with DVD2One and instant copy on a 7.6 gig movie with instant copy just edging out DVD2One. For a movie like Return of The King the difference would be obvious and instant copy would be better suited for the task,(although I did successfully back an unpixeled Return of The King with DVD2one).
Another point I can make is that I usually go for the movie only and that also reduces file size considerably. There are movies however like Return of The King and Rock Concerts where trimming isn't an option and high quality compression is.
To sum, at given sizes where visual differences really aren't there I'm going to go for speed and save time. I am however going to purchase instant copy because it seems more trustworthy than Intervideos DVDcopy and it does it for less than half the price. I'm going to continue to use it until the two week trial is up in case I find a bug in it like those found in DVDcopy.
" Please Read!!! Post your questions only in This Thread or they will go unanswered:
Help with development of BD RB: Donations at: http://www.jdobbs.com/.
|
brian100
Suspended due to non-functional email address
|
7. June 2004 @ 07:52 |
Link to this message
|
Bigorange
Welcome to the Pinnacle appreciation society !, now if I can persuade you to try DVDrebuilder & buy CCE basic (about $50), you will be cooking with major gas!.
Rebuilder/CCE basic leaves Pinnacle far in it's wake.
I backed up my Aliens DVD with CCE & could see NO difference between original & back-up.
ps No more bragging about the 56" HD TV or I will throw you a serious bum stear :)
Looking for my old AD
This message has been edited since posting. Last time this message was edited on 7. June 2004 @ 07:53
|
AfterDawn Addict
|
7. June 2004 @ 08:14 |
Link to this message
|
Brian, didn't realize I was, sooorry, just wanted you to know that it was judged on something that would show flaws. Does CCE have a trial version?
GO VOLS !
This message has been edited since posting. Last time this message was edited on 7. July 2004 @ 16:47
|
AfterDawn Addict
1 product review
|
7. June 2004 @ 08:22 |
Link to this message
|
bigorange
The 56 inch TV is a rear projeciton made by whom? Just curious. I've been debating getting a larger screen HD screen.BTW DVD box just did a review on pinnacle.
" Please Read!!! Post your questions only in This Thread or they will go unanswered:
Help with development of BD RB: Donations at: http://www.jdobbs.com/.
This message has been edited since posting. Last time this message was edited on 7. June 2004 @ 08:24
|
brian100
Suspended due to non-functional email address
|
7. June 2004 @ 08:25 |
Link to this message
|
Bigorange
I wasnt having a pop at you about your telly. I am just dead jealous that yours is bigger than mine!!. 44" is big enough for me though!!. (Said the actress to the bishop)
Can i tell you summat straight mate?. With your 56" TV you seriously owe it to yourself to buy CCE basic. There is not a trial version available (i dont think!).
If you are happy to run this setup overnight & truly care about image quality, then it's right up your street. The alternative, of course, is to wait until Dual Layer blanks come down in price & adopt that technology.
Looking for my old AD
|
AfterDawn Addict
|
7. June 2004 @ 08:28 |
Link to this message
|
Mitsibishi, I still have the first one I ever bought, a 27" 20 years ago. They make Great video. PS- CCE have a trialware?
|
AfterDawn Addict
1 product review
|
7. June 2004 @ 08:31 |
Link to this message
|
bigorange
forget the request I read your earlier post and it was there.
" Please Read!!! Post your questions only in This Thread or they will go unanswered:
Help with development of BD RB: Donations at: http://www.jdobbs.com/.
This message has been edited since posting. Last time this message was edited on 7. June 2004 @ 08:56
|
AfterDawn Addict
|
7. June 2004 @ 08:34 |
Link to this message
|
The question I must ask of course is: user friendly? Gotta remember I'm just a poor ole dumb country boy. I actually downloaded dvd rebuilder til I realized I needed CCE to go with it. Seems like at the time it was substantually higher than 50.00 This was a while back when I first got into this vein and I was downloading everything and anything to do with video back-up. PS-I just put a bid on a dual layer burner by Lite On,SOHW 832S. Know much about them?
GO VOLS !
This message has been edited since posting. Last time this message was edited on 7. July 2004 @ 16:48
|
swmiller
Suspended due to non-functional email address
|
7. June 2004 @ 09:31 |
Link to this message
|
|
AfterDawn Addict
|
7. June 2004 @ 09:59 |
Link to this message
|
Hey swmiller, mine's on all nite cos i'm up talking in this forum. lol Tried your link, couldn't get it to work. Found a link for trial version for 2,000.00 SP. No need for that one cos no way I'm buying that. Is your link for basic?
GO VOLS !
This message has been edited since posting. Last time this message was edited on 7. July 2004 @ 16:48
|
AfterDawn Addict
1 product review
|
7. June 2004 @ 11:06 |
Link to this message
|
Speaking of taking too much time on this forum, I've got to take a break. As a teacher I have the entire summer off and I don't think it would be in my best interest to spend it all on afterdawn.
" Please Read!!! Post your questions only in This Thread or they will go unanswered:
Help with development of BD RB: Donations at: http://www.jdobbs.com/.
|
brian100
Suspended due to non-functional email address
|
7. June 2004 @ 11:53 |
Link to this message
|
Bigorange
I know nothing about the new dual layer burners that are coming out. I do know that the blank media is going to be quite expensive, initially. The cost of bearing coasters may end up causing a suicidal effect on the user. I am going to sit back and let "others" experience all the new quirks & issues before, or even if, I adopt this new technology.
To be totally blunt, I really can't see the need for dual layer at present. The vast majority of titles can be backed up, adequately, using the app's discussed on this thread. If I were you I would hang back (& hope you are outbid!) for the time being.
Just my 2 cents.
Looking for my old AD
|
AfterDawn Addict
1 product review
|
7. June 2004 @ 11:58 |
Link to this message
|
I second that it's the same logic I used before I bought my PLextor.
" Please Read!!! Post your questions only in This Thread or they will go unanswered:
Help with development of BD RB: Donations at: http://www.jdobbs.com/.
|
Advertisement
|
|
|
Member
|
7. June 2004 @ 12:12 |
Link to this message
|
I plan on waiting until they get the kinks worked out on dual layer burners as well as burner software compatibality.
For my WD800JB 80 GB HD which I will put in a firewire case to use just for burning.
It was a bare drive and did not have any software with it.
Someone told me to use the MAX Floppie to format the drive as it would format it in nothing flat.
Does anyone know where I might download this tool.
Tom
HP 7975 Pentium 4W/2.0 XP Home
1 GB RAM
Maxtor 80 GB and WD 80 GB (used for movies only)
Pioneer 116 DVD ROM,and BenQ 1640 Combo
|