|
Should I buy the PS3 edition or Xbox edition?
|
|
|
Xintruder
Account closed as per user's own request
|
31. October 2007 @ 10:47 |
Link to this message
|
Hello,
I own both consoles. I love both consoles. I play for fun, and I am not asking what console is better. These days many games are coming / came out on both consoles. COD4, Jerricho, assassins creed. The question is: What edition of the game should I buy, the ps3 or xbox360 edition?
I had both consoles since launch, I would choose the PS3 edition in the past because I use HDMI (1080p or something), while the older 360 only had component cable (720 max). Now that I bought the elite I don't know what to buy.
I buy resistance for ps3, halo for xbox, what it gets to: same game on both consols I don't know what to buy :(
Help me!
|
|
Advertisement
|
|
|
|
Senior Member
|
31. October 2007 @ 11:32 |
Link to this message
|
|
Aside from small graphical differences these games are going to look the same. So the only question you'll really have to ask yourself is which controller feels better in your hand? The other question you might want ask yourself is if you plan to play with the online community. The 360 has a larger online community, so if online matters you may want to join the 360 camp.
X360 - iXtreme1.4 ||| Xbox - EvoX Dash ||| PS2 - CC 2.0 PRO SLE ||| Dreamcast ...lol ||| NDS - Acekard 2/M3 Simply/EZ Flash 3-1 ||| Rooted HTC Hero with Ic3rom
|
|
Xintruder
Account closed as per user's own request
|
31. October 2007 @ 12:37 |
Link to this message
|
|
Thanks for your quick answer!
Does everybody agree on which console has the 'little' graphic advantage, or is it still deated....?
What about sound (5.1), are they the same?
Single player stuff, same?
future addons and extentions, same?
Future exclusive stuff..., is it true that assasins creed (for example) will have its own exclusive extentions in uture, and xbox will be different.. and so on ??
|
|
ziggi_83
Senior Member
|
31. October 2007 @ 14:16 |
Link to this message
|
If you have a Hdtv get the games on Ps3 as the ps3 graphics are better.
Did you have Ps2 or xbox, if you had ps2 you probably be more used to the ps3 controls.
Yh single player will be the same
Not sure about the Assassins Creed stuff
|
Senior Member
|
31. October 2007 @ 15:51 |
Link to this message
|
I realize this is the PS3 board so I don't want to offend anyone, but the graphics on PS3 aren't necessarily going to be better than the 360 with the games that Xintruder listed.
These games are being developed with both systems in mind and did not have separate development from the ground up for each system. That process would be inefficient and very costly. Essentially what I'm getting at is that the graphical differences with the games Xintruder listed will be very little because the games were developed together then optimized for each system.
Here is a graphics comparison with games available on both systems. Mouse over the images to see the differenced on the 360 and PS3. There are positives and negatives for both systems but they are minimal differences.
@ziggi_83
The 360 displays games in HD... Your statement alluded that the 360 doesn't when it actually does...
X360 - iXtreme1.4 ||| Xbox - EvoX Dash ||| PS2 - CC 2.0 PRO SLE ||| Dreamcast ...lol ||| NDS - Acekard 2/M3 Simply/EZ Flash 3-1 ||| Rooted HTC Hero with Ic3rom
This message has been edited since posting. Last time this message was edited on 31. October 2007 @ 15:57
|
|
thegrunt
Senior Member
|
31. October 2007 @ 17:08 |
Link to this message
|
|
Either one,its the same game
Houston Rockets,its our year.Yao,T-Mac,Francis,Scola,James,Alston,Battier,Wells,and so much more talent,its inevitable. |
|
ziggi_83
Senior Member
|
31. October 2007 @ 17:43 |
Link to this message
|
Originally posted by Joshewah:
I realize this is the PS3 board so I don't want to offend anyone, but the graphics on PS3 aren't necessarily going to be better than the 360 with the games that Xintruder listed.
These games are being developed with both systems in mind and did not have separate development from the ground up for each system. That process would be inefficient and very costly. Essentially what I'm getting at is that the graphical differences with the games Xintruder listed will be very little because the games were developed together then optimized for each system.
Here is a graphics comparison with games available on both systems. Mouse over the images to see the differenced on the 360 and PS3. There are positives and negatives for both systems but they are minimal differences.
@ziggi_83
The 360 displays games in HD... Your statement alluded that the 360 doesn't when it actually does...
Mate i know 360 has HD as i have one i meant 1080p because of Blu-ray
Just because the gaems will be coming out on both consoels doesnt mean it will have the same graphics
|
Senior Member
|
31. October 2007 @ 22:35 |
Link to this message
|
|
Also, just because the games will be coming out on both consoles doesn't mean the PS3 will have better graphics. As I said before, both systems have their graphical pros and cons.
X360 - iXtreme1.4 ||| Xbox - EvoX Dash ||| PS2 - CC 2.0 PRO SLE ||| Dreamcast ...lol ||| NDS - Acekard 2/M3 Simply/EZ Flash 3-1 ||| Rooted HTC Hero with Ic3rom
|
|
Edgewise
Member
|
31. October 2007 @ 23:36 |
Link to this message
|
It comes down to how the devs develop and optimize for each system. For example, if they make the game on 360 and do a (probably shitty) port job (refer to most EA titles) then the 360 will most likely have slighter better graphics (and vise-versa), especially when it comes to anti-aliasing for some reason (memory?). That's just coming from my experience.
I would think assassin's creed started on ps3 because it was an exclusive at one point, but then again they had to cut corners or something I'm sure to make it about the same size as a DVD9 because of the 360 version, which is totally disappointing.
Assassin's Creed and COD4 aren't out yet so its impossible to say which system they will look better on. Jericho I'm not too sure about.
My guess is that they will be almost identical on both consoles anyway.
This message has been edited since posting. Last time this message was edited on 31. October 2007 @ 23:40
|
Senior Member
|
2. November 2007 @ 10:07 |
Link to this message
|
|
Get the 360 version it has achievements.
|
|
ziggi_83
Senior Member
|
2. November 2007 @ 14:14 |
Link to this message
|
|
Dont listen to that 360 fanboy, have you got warranty on your xbox? You never know when it will commit suicide. Its down to you, what do you like when it comes to controller etc Xbox360 or Ps3
|
|
cd250481
Junior Member
|
2. November 2007 @ 14:46 |
Link to this message
|
You'll probably think I'm saying as i own a PS3 but i wouldn't buy a xbox 360 only really because of this " red ring of death" thing where the 360 as a hardware failure then shows you 3 red lights in that ring of lights on the front. Just check this site, full of xbox360 buyers complaining about it.
http://www.360maniac.com/2006/01/30/repair-xbox-360-3-red-lights/
page goes on and on and on
Hope this helps your decision.
|
Member
|
2. November 2007 @ 15:01 |
Link to this message
|
|
Also own both ps3 and a xbox, There is one point that should also be addressed. Namely at the moment ps3 really lacks any real working social network/online gaming system that availably on the xbox. Until Home comes out some time next year, hopefully 1Q (but no promises); xbox360 live network and the game benefits that come from that are considerable.
So achievements, live support, in-game chat/coms with people outgame and ingame, are currently in the 360:s favor.
BUT if your a person that values one player gaming more, then the more powerful ps3 should offer you more value.
(note: this comes down to how well they have coded the games to utilize the ps3:s features, good bet is to check out the reviews that come out of the games and pay attention to platform comparison reviews)
my two cc.
- Ora
"Making backups and reading easy to find guides are for Noobs, better to dick around and cry on the forums once it all goes to hell." - 95% of Noobs on the forum
This message has been edited since posting. Last time this message was edited on 2. November 2007 @ 15:04
|
|
ziggi_83
Senior Member
|
2. November 2007 @ 15:12 |
Link to this message
|
Originally posted by Oraseth:
Also own both ps3 and a xbox, There is one point that should also be addressed. Namely at the moment ps3 really lacks any real working social network/online gaming system that availably on the xbox. Until Home comes out some time next year, hopefully 1Q (but no promises); xbox360 live network and the game benefits that come from that are considerable.
So achievements, live support, in-game chat/coms with people outgame and ingame, are currently in the 360:s favor.
BUT if your a person that values one player gaming more, then the more powerful ps3 should offer you more value.
(note: this comes down to how well they have coded the games to utilize the ps3:s features, good bet is to check out the reviews that come out of the games and pay attention to platform comparison reviews)
my two cc.
- Ora
So what would you choose?
|
Senior Member
|
2. November 2007 @ 15:48 |
Link to this message
|
Originally posted by Oraseth:
Also own both ps3 and a xbox, There is one point that should also be addressed. Namely at the moment ps3 really lacks any real working social network/online gaming system that availably on the xbox. Until Home comes out some time next year, hopefully 1Q (but no promises); xbox360 live network and the game benefits that come from that are considerable.
So achievements, live support, in-game chat/coms with people outgame and ingame, are currently in the 360:s favor.
BUT if your a person that values one player gaming more, then the more powerful ps3 should offer you more value.
(note: this comes down to how well they have coded the games to utilize the ps3:s features, good bet is to check out the reviews that come out of the games and pay attention to platform comparison reviews)
my two cc.
- Ora
Great post. I agree with both ends of your statement.
Originally posted by ziggi_83:
So what would you choose?
I think he did right by not choosing... The point of this thread is create a neutral environment so Xintruder can choose on his own which system he'd like. Playing the console popularity contest is is just going to create a system slam fest with no real conclusion, a fanboy favorite.
X360 - iXtreme1.4 ||| Xbox - EvoX Dash ||| PS2 - CC 2.0 PRO SLE ||| Dreamcast ...lol ||| NDS - Acekard 2/M3 Simply/EZ Flash 3-1 ||| Rooted HTC Hero with Ic3rom
|
Senior Member
3 product reviews
|
2. November 2007 @ 16:14 |
Link to this message
|
Originally posted by OmriSama:
Get the 360 version it has achievements.
This has been bothering me for a while Omri; why the bloody hell do u troll the ps3 boards looking for any chance to praise the 360 or shoot off about the ps3. Furthermore you never really give any half decent reasons why anything is good or bad. Seriously buzz off.
This message has been edited since posting. Last time this message was edited on 2. November 2007 @ 18:15
|
|
Xintruder
Account closed as per user's own request
|
2. November 2007 @ 16:57 |
Link to this message
|
|
Hello guys and thank you all for your input. All your statements is something I complement and value much.
I came up with this following conclusions, since I have both consoles (PS3 and Xbox360):
1) Go for the Xbox360 version of game if I want to be envolved in the Online community, such as COD4, GRAW2, Vegas, etc.
2) Select the more comforting controller for the game. For example Pro evolution soccer is better for me in PS3 than 360 (used to be a winning 11 player), and COD is better for me in 360.
3) Try to research what was the game programmed to be on, such as Assasins Creed for PS3. I'm sure I will see games I wouldn't know what was it planned to be in, such as jerricho.
I just hope both consoles will launch extremely good exclusives and I will get both games and be envolved in this ever lasting console war! j/k kind of..
As for the achievements, I know some player enjoy them but as for me I don't know how it benifits me?! I had something like over 4000 ( of points or somthing), and I have no clue whats the points are or how is this helpfull to me, like what happends?!?!?
Have a good day all and thanks for your input guys! :)
|
Member
|
2. November 2007 @ 17:40 |
Link to this message
|
Originally posted by Xintruder:
3) Try to research what was the game programmed to be on, such as Assasins Creed for PS3. I'm sure I will see games I wouldn't know what was it planned to be in, such as jerricho.
Well... the main problem with the ps3 is that the programing language for the ps3 is fairly unique, and that it really does not apply to anything other than for the ps3. Because of this coders need to learn a new language just to be able to make games on for the ps3.People are somewhat reluctant commit to making games for it, since the Microsoft xbox 360:s language XNA is much closer to more commonly used languages like C# or .NET. Its simply easier to make games for the 360.
The other biggest problem for ps3 is that people really are not good enough in coding for it, and they are not really using much of the capabilities of the device. As time goes on and people get more experience coding for it, the games will improve dramatically.
Originally posted by Xintruder:
As for the achievements, I know some player enjoy them but as for me I don't know how it benifits me?! I had something like over 4000 ( of points or somthing), and I have no clue whats the points are or how is this helpfull to me, like what happends?!?!?
Well, Thats pretty much it, people can see what games you have played, as well as what achievements you have unlocked. Also useful if you make a friend on live and you add them to you friends list, you can see what games they may have so you can try inviting them to join you in a game or two...
As for happens or gets... thats about it. Its really just for your own entertainment as well as a social thing. :D
"Making backups and reading easy to find guides are for Noobs, better to dick around and cry on the forums once it all goes to hell." - 95% of Noobs on the forum
This message has been edited since posting. Last time this message was edited on 2. November 2007 @ 17:50
|
Senior Member
3 product reviews
|
2. November 2007 @ 18:14 |
Link to this message
|
|
srry mispost.
This message has been edited since posting. Last time this message was edited on 2. November 2007 @ 18:14
|
AfterDawn Addict
|
4. November 2007 @ 04:14 |
Link to this message
|
Originally posted by ziggi_83:
Mate i know 360 has HD as i have one i meant 1080p because of Blu-ray
Just because the gaems will be coming out on both consoels doesnt mean it will have the same graphics
The 360 does 1080P through both VGA and HDMI. And Blu Ray has nothing to do with the PS3 outputting at 1080P.
Originally posted by ziggi_83:
Dont listen to that 360 fanboy, have you got warranty on your xbox? You never know when it will commit suicide.
And that's not a fan boy statement...
Quote:
Assassin's Creed and COD4 aren't out yet so its impossible to say which system they will look better on. Jericho I'm not too sure about.
My guess is that they will be almost identical on both consoles anyway.
I read awhile back that IGN (I believe) reported that the PS3 version of CoD4 was graphically better. So it might be worth grabbing it for the PS3.
|
|
warKRY
Suspended due to non-functional email address
|
4. November 2007 @ 05:42 |
Link to this message
|
im a bit of a 360 fanatic (halo 3) but ultimately its down to the controllers and online benefits
u wont need online 4 assassins creed, though
so i say the 360 =)
|
|
ziggi_83
Senior Member
|
4. November 2007 @ 06:17 |
Link to this message
|
|
@ Bhetrick
If you read the ps3 forum reguarly you would have noticed he pops in and out to support the xbox or say negatives about ps3
And i have an xbox and it died on me many times so i can say what i want without being called a ps3 fanboy.
Well which console are you going to choose to play your games on.
|
AfterDawn Addict
|
4. November 2007 @ 07:04 |
Link to this message
|
Originally posted by ziggi_83:
@ Bhetrick
If you read the ps3 forum reguarly you would have noticed he pops in and out to support the xbox or say negatives about ps3
And i have an xbox and it died on me many times so i can say what i want without being called a ps3 fanboy.
Well which console are you going to choose to play your games on.
Alright... then I'm sorry. I don't want to get into the whole "my console has a bigger dick than your's" arguement.
When it comes to talking about games, I prefer the PS3 forum. You guys talk more about games here than over in the 360 forum. Over there it always "how do I make a backup" or "how do I flash a drive".
I picked up a 20 gig PS3 at launch, but returned it 3 weeks later. There weren't any games for it that I didn't already have for the 360. I'm waiting for a handful of exclusive PS3 games (that I want) before I pick up another one.
But lately I've had the itch to buy something new just for the hell of it... and the PS3 keeps coming to mind. http://forums.afterdawn.com/thread_view.cfm/575531
Last month I sold my 42" LG Plasma and bought a 50" Samsung from Best Buy, so I've got about $60 in Reward Zone coupons coming in a couple days. So I may just pick up a PS3 now.
Really, for CoD4, it'll be which ever offers better multiplayer, as I'll be playing that online alot. As for the other games which I'll focus more on the story mode, it'll be which ever offers better game play and the most content. I've read articles before where the 360 may lose content in the future due to space limitations.
Games I'd be looking forward to: Haze, Killzone 2, and probally Uncharted. I prefer fps's, but Uncharted looks good.
|
|
ziggi_83
Senior Member
|
4. November 2007 @ 07:48 |
Link to this message
|
lol.
I got my ps3 before my xbox 360 and i have been playing resistance since i got it, i want to get all the medals and so far im kinda close, well i switch on halo 3 now and again but i tend to play resistance and Warhawk more. Which games did you get when you brought your console? Resistance and Warhawk has been enough for me lol, but i think nows the time you get one e.g. HAZE!
|
|
Advertisement
|
|
|
AfterDawn Addict
|
4. November 2007 @ 09:22 |
Link to this message
|
Resistance was the only thing available at the time. Other than Call of Duty 3, of course, but I has already beat that awhile before on the Xbox.
Only really caring for fps's and looking at the time frame of future releases, I decided to return the PS3. It did take me a few weeks to decide, but now looking back I did. It would have just collected dust.
Things are finally looking betters so I'm ready to grab another one.
|
